The Second Word, by Venerable Fulton Sheen, 8 March 1936

“Amen I say to thee, this day thou shalt be with me in paradise” – Luke 32:43

1952 photograph of Venerable Fulton John Sheen produced as promotional material for the television show 'Life is Worth Living'This is now the offertory of the Mass, for Our Lord is offering Himself to His Heavenly Father. But in order to remind us that He is not offered alone, but in union with us. He unites with His offertory the soul of the thief at the right. To make His ignominy more complete, in a master stroke of malice, they crucified Him between two thieves. He walked among sinners during His life, so now they let Him hang among them at death. But He changed the picture, and made the two thieves the symbols of the sheep and the goats, which will stand at His right and left hand when He comes in the clouds of heaven, with His then triumphant Cross, to judge both the living and the dead.

Both thieves at first reviled and blasphemed, but one of them, whom tradition calls Dismas, turned his head to read the meekness and dignity on the face of the Crucified Savior. As a piece of coal thrown into the fire is transformed into a bright and glowing thing, so the black soul of this thief thrown into the fires of the Crucifixion glowed with love for the Sacred Heart. While the thief on the left was saying: “If thou be Christ, save thyself and us”, the repentant thief rebuked him saying: “Neither dost thou fear God, seeing thou art under the same condemnation. And we indeed justly, for we receive the due reward of our deeds; but this man hath done no evil”. That same thief then emitted a plea, not for a place in the seats of the mighty, but only for a remembrance not to be forgotten.

Such sorrow and faith must not go unrewarded. At a moment when the power of Rome could not make Him speak, when His friends thought all was lost and His enemies believed alj was won. Our Lord broke the silence. He who was the accused, became thfe Judge; He who was the crucified, became the Divine Assessor of souls, as to the penitent thief He trumpeted the words: “This day thou shalt be with me in paradise”. This day – when you said your first prayer and your last; this day – thou shalt be with Me – and where I am, there is Paradise.

With these words Our Lord who was offering Himself to His Heavenly Father on the paten of His Cross as the great host, now unites with Him on the paten of the cross the first small host ever offered in the Mass – the host of a repentant thief, a brand plucked from the burning, a sheaf torn from the earthly reapers, the wheat ground in the mill of the crucifixion and made bread for the Eucharist.

Our Lord then does not suffer alone on the Cross: He suffers with us. That is why He united the sacrifice of the thief with His own. It is just this Saint Paul means when he says that we should fill up those things that are wanting to the sufferings of Christ. This does not mean Our Lord on the cross did not suffer all He could. It means rather that the physical historical Christ suffered all He could in His own human nature, but that the Mystical Christ, which is Christ and us, has not suffered to our fullness. All the other good thieves in the history of the world have not yet admitted their wrong and pleaded for remembrance. Our Lord is now in heaven. He therefore can suffer no more in His human nature but He can suffer more in our human natures. And so He reaches out to other human natures, to yours and mine, and asks us to do as the thief did, namely to incorporate ourselves to Him on the Cross, that sharing in His Crucifixion we might also share in His Resurrection, and that made partakers of His cross we might also be made partakers of His glory in heaven.

As our Blessed Lord on that day chose the thief as the small Host of Sacrifice, he chooses us today as the other small hosts united with Him on the Paten of the altar. Go back in your mind’s eye to a Mass, to any Mass which was celebrated in the first centuries of the Church, before civilization became completely financial and economic. If we went to the Holy Sacrifice in the early Church, we would have brought to the altar each morning some bread and some wine. The priest would have used one piece of that unleavened bread and some of that wine for the sacrifice of the Mass. The rest would have been put aside, blessed, and distributed to the poor. Today we do not bring bread and wine. We bring its equivalent; we bring that which buys bread and wine. Hence the offertory collection.

Now, why do we bring bread and wine or its equivalent to the Mass? We bring bread and wine because these two things, of all things in nature, most represent the substance of life. Wheat is as the very marrow of the ground, and the grapes its very blood, both of which give us the marrow and blood of life. In bringing those two things, which give us life, nourish us, we are equivalently bringing ourselves to the Sacrifice of the Mass. We are therefore present at each and every Mass under the appearance of bread and wine, which stand as symbols of our body and blood. We are not passive spectators as we might be watching a spectacle in a theatre, but we are co-offering our Mass with Christ.

If any picture adequately describes our role in this drama it is this: There is a great cross before us on which is stretched the great Host, Christ. Round about the hill of Calvary are our small crosses on which we, the small hosts, are to be offered. When Our Lord goes to His Cross we go to our little crosses, and offer ourselves in union with Him, as a clean oblation to the Heavenly Father.

At that moment we literally fulfill to the smallest detail the Savior’s command: Take up your cross daily and follow Me. And in doing so. He is not asking us to do anything He has not already done Himself. Nor is it any excuse to say: “I am a poor unworthy host”. So was the thief.

Note that there were two attitudes in the soul of that thief, both of which made him acceptable to Our Lord. The first was the recognition of the fact that He deserved what He was suffering, but that the sinless Christ did not deserve His Cross; in other words, he was penitent. The second was faith, faith in Him whom men rejected, but whom the thief recognized as the very King of Kings.

Upon what conditions do we become small hosts in the Mass? How does our sacrifice become one with Christ’s and as acceptable as the thief’s? Only by reproducing in our souls the two attitudes in the soul of the Thief: penitence and faith.

First of all we must be penitent with the thief and say: “I deserve punishment for my sins. I stand in need of sacrifice.” Some of us do not know how wicked or how ungrateful to God we are. If we did, we would not complain so about the shocks and pains of life. Our consciences are like darkened rooms from which light has been long excluded. We draw the curtain, and lo! everywhere before we thought was cleanliness, we find dust. Only a conscience that has been filmed over with excuses prays the prayer of the Pharisee: “I thank Thee, O God, that I am not as the rest of men”. They blaspheme the God of heaven for their pain and sins and they repent not. The World War was meant to be a purgation of evil; it was meant to teach us that we can not get along without God, but the world refused to learn the lesson. Like the thief on the left, it refuses to be penitent: it refuses to see any relation of justice between sin and sacrifice, between rebellion and a cross. But the more penitent we are, the less anxious we are to escape our cross. The more we see ourselves as we are, the more we say with the good thief: ‘T deserved this cross”. He did not want to be excused; he did not want to have his sin explained away; he did not want to be let off; He did not ask to be taken down. He wanted only to be forgiven. He was willing even to be a small host on his own little cross – but that was because he was penitent. Nor is there given to us any other way to become little hosts with Christ in the Mass, than breaking our hearts with sorrow; for unless we admit we are wounded how can we feel the need of healing? Unless we are sorry for our part in the Crucifixion, how could we ever ask to be forgiven its sin?

The second condition of becoming a host in the offertory of the Mass is faith. The thief looked upon our Blessed Lord and he saw a sign above His head which read: “KING”. Queer king that! For a crown: thorns. For royal purple: His own blood. For a throne: a cross. For courtiers: executioners. For a coronation: a crucifixion. And yet beneath all that dross the thief saw the gold; amidst all those blasphemies he prayed.

And his faith was so strong he was content to remain on his cross. The thief on the left asked to be taken down, but not the thief on the right. Why? Because he knew there were greater evils than crucifixions, and another life beyond the cross. He had faith in the Man on the central cross who could have turned thorns into garlands and nails into rosebuds if He willed; he had faith in a Kingdom beyond the Cross, knowing that the sufferings of this world are not worthy to be compared with the joys that are to come. With the Psalmist his soul cried: “Though I should walk in the midst of the shadow of death I will fear no evils, for thou art with me”.

Such faith was like that of the three youths in the fiery furnace who were commanded by the king, Nebuchadnezzar, to adore the golden statue. Their answer was: “For behold our God, whom we worship, is able to save us from the furnace of burning fire, and to deliver us out of thy hands, O king. But if He will not, be it known to thee, O king, that we will not worship thy gods, nor adore the golden statue which thou hast set up” – note that they did not ask God to deliver them from the fiery furnace, though they knew God could do it – for He “is able to save us from the furnace of burning fire”. They left themselves wholly in God’s hands, and like Job trusted Him though they were slain. So likewise with the good thief: He knew Our Lord could deliver Him. But He did not ask to he taken down from the cross, for Our Lord did not come down Himself even though the mob challenged Him. The thief would be a small host, if need be, unto the very end of the Mass. This did not mean the thief did not love life: He loved life as much as we love it. He wanted life, and a long life, and he found it, for what life is longer than Life Eternal? To each and every one of us in like manner it is given to discover that Eternal Life. But there is no other way to enter it than by penance and by faith which unite us to that Great Host – the Priest and Victim Christ. . . Thus do we become Spiritual Thieves, and steal heaven once again.